Hacker News Reader

Comment by matheusmoreira | Hacker News Reader

Brazil's president Lula certainly wants this. He's been pushing for it for years now. I see it in the news every other day. I suppose it's possible that he's just the fall guy for the machinations of China and Russia. Who knows.

I'm ambivalent about it. Having our own currency is good, even better if it's not backed by USD, best of all if it's backed by precious metals like gold. On the other hand, I hate Lula and everything he represents so much I actually want him to piss Trump off to the point he sanctions the entire Latin American continent until Lula and his fellow communist dictator friends drop to their knees and beg for mercy.

View on HN

You do know that we used to have currencies backed by gold, and it was so awful that it caused the great depression right?

We had currencies backed by gold for hundreds of years before the great depression without anything equivalent happening. The great depression happened soon after US momentary creation was handed over to the private Federal Reserve.

> The great depression happened soon after US momentary creation was handed over to the private Federal Reserve

Correlation =/= Causation.

The Great Depression was caused by American overproduction and a lack of domestic buyers who could afford to purchase American goods (sound familiar?). This was back when America was still functionally a developing country.

The Panic of 1837 (followed by a five year depression) would like a word. And the panic of 1873 (four year depression), the depression of 1882, the panic of 1893, and the panic of 1907.

We had metal standards way after the great depression, till 1971. Bretton Woods system made USD an international reserve currency, but its convertibility to gold was guaranteed. In 1971 US gov decided to not guarantee that anymore, because it gave a ridiculous advantage to US. Germany was rhe first county to left Bretton Woods, France sent a battleship to collect gold in exchange for US dollar reserves etc.. and the system collapsed. It's called Nixon shock I think.

So, leaving the international system helped the European economies greatly then. It makes sense some other countries are having the same idea now.

The USD to gold exchange guarantee ended in the early 70s, long after the great depression. And there have been many economic meltdowns since then. The two are not related.

When the economy is backed by something real, credit generally keeps up with the broader economy. It can't expand beyond reserves of real resources. Now that the money is not backed by anything, credit can expand infinitely. Credit generates most of the inflation which is a direct and ever increasing tax on the poor. It has been going on for half a century and shows no sign of stopping. The best part is even the mere attempt to stop it will cause a meltdown since the economy is addicted to credit.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com