If someone says he's betting on stock X, the opposite is not to go short. That's one way of doing "not what he did". Another way of doing "not what he did" is to for example sell a PUT, because maybe you think it's just going to stay flat. Another way is to not do anything, and instead wait, because going short costs money (you're borrowing a stock and borrowing fees on it), and so the act of shorting itself can lose you money if he isn't "wrong fast enough". So is the opposite to short it on the day he says he's buying, or is the opposite to short it the next week? Even "pure opposite" situations would require exact entrypoints and exit points which you wouldn't have.
You literally fell for the exact thing I was describing.