No, they do not differ by an infinitesimal. You picked an arbitrary infinite N and found the derivative to be N/4. What if you picked N^2? or 2^N? or some upper limit set whose existence is stronger than choice? You get a different derivative every time and they all differ by an infinity between them. Good luck explaining that to high school students.
Moreover, working with equivalence relations is never a feature of any theory. Having to prove independence from representative at every step is not a feature, as you clearly demonstrate by making the mistake above.
> I've done a course in analysis that covered distributions, but your reply made me chuckle. You've told me that distributions are just as simple and then proceeded to dump paragraphs of jargon at me. L^infinity? Dual space? Support? Penrose defined? Inner product via integrals?
All concepts that are simple to define and understand. Majority of physicists likely understand well. Those that don’t, could.
Paragraphs of jargon? i’ve rigorously proven and justified my further assertions, at a similar level to OP and above what i’ve seen in some physics lectures.
I deliberately decided to avoid defining the above “jargon” terms after considering doing that to avoid extending the already long comment. I decided this because they are simple and a curious mind could quickly understand them by browsing wikipedia.
You’re welcome to ignore them and to go and compute derivatives and integrals just as mechanistically as in NSA (and I repeat, we haven’t even mentioned integrals in NSA. Good luck defining what are measurable functions on the hyperreals to your hypothetical AP high school students).
And to boot we never have to deal with any quantities that are not real measurable numbers. Anything we care about we can compute, more easily (integrals? integrals??) this way.
That is not to say that this isn’t an interesting theory that should be studied - just that it is quite the opposite of a “simplified” approach to general functions