In the states, I think most people I know are familiar with "eastern time" or "pacific time." But I doubt that many of my friends recognize "Americas/New_York" or appreciate why they need to select that instead of "Americas/Indianapolis" when referencing eastern time[1]. I certainly wasn't familiar with referencing timezones this way until I had a job that cared a whole lot about timezones and had offices in several countries!
I like the idea of solving this by just asking for the location of an event.
[1] having lived in indiana a while ago, I'm assuming that Indianapolis gets its own TZ entry because it wasn't on daylight savings back in the 90s (?). Which was pretty annoying.