Unless you're talking about someone using a mocked up Square reader to do something malicious like harvest credit card information with a custom application or something. In which case you should be terrified of all card readers.
This sounds like you're diluting your opinion with a bit of confirmation bias. Yes, credit cards are vulnerable. But do you have any idea how easy it is for a scammer to stick a fake front plate on an ATM and harvest your account information that way?
The world is a scary place, but you can't use the fact that there's bad people in the world to shoot down a credit/debit card based fundraising tool.