"It's [...] not right" (from your first comment), can you give/link a specific physical example? It would be very cool to have a clear counterexample.
"It's [...] not right" (from your first comment), can you give/link a specific physical example? It would be very cool to have a clear counterexample.
About the lack of subjectivity of the states? If we consider any bit of matter (for example a crystal or an ideal gas), the macrostate is completely independent of the observer: it’s just the state in which the law of physics say that bit of matter should be. In an ideal gas it is entirely determined by the pressure and volume, which are anything but subjective. For a crystal it is more complex because we have to account for things like its shape but the reasoning is the same.
Then, the microstates are just accessible states, and this is also dictated by Physics. For example, it is quite easy to see that a crystal has fewer accessible states than a gas (the atoms’ positions are constrained and the velocities are limited to the crystal’s vibration modes). We can calculate the entropy in the experimental conditions within that framework, or in the case of correlated liquids, or amorphous solids, or whatever. But the fact that we can come up with different entropies if we make different hypotheses does not mean that any of these hypotheses is actually valid. If we measure the entropy directly we might have a value that is consistent with several models, or none. The actual entropy is what we observe, not the theoretical scaffolding we use to try to make sense of it. And again, this is not subjective.
Is there a concrete physical example where the information-theory definition of entropy conflicts with experiment?
Of course, the example I gave is arguable, since the two observers are not actually observing the same process. One is looking at enc(x), the other is looking at x. They would both agree that enc(x) has high entropy, and x has low entropy. But this same kind of phenomenon doesn't work with physical entropy. A gas is going to burn my hand or not regardless of how well I know its microstates.
Or perhaps that's the secret of the Shaolin monks!
If you already agree that the two are distinct measures, I believe there is no disagreement in the sub-thread.