I assume ultimately users will need to grant the permission for these things?
If Apple did their part to inform user of the consequences, and yet user decides to allow access, who is Apple to judge?
I assume ultimately users will need to grant the permission for these things?
If Apple did their part to inform user of the consequences, and yet user decides to allow access, who is Apple to judge?
- Telegram permanently shows an in-app notification if you haven't granted access to all your contacts.
- WhatsApp won't show nicknames in your conversation list or individual conversations if you haven't granted access to all your contacts (the nicknames are visible in some other screen, so this isn't a case of missing data).
The user will get to decide, but the user won't get to decide _freely_. Some other annoyance will be introduced until you decide to grant all the access they demand.
> WhatsApp won't show nicknames in your conversation list or individual conversations if you haven't granted access to all your contacts
Hrm, are you in the EU? I ask because neither appear to be the case for me, but I'm in the EU; the GDPR generally doesn't allow penalising the user for declining to consent to data collection (though compliance with this is patchy currently).
And the problem with companies like Meta is that their terms of service are so complex and indecipherable that it’s almost a certainty you will approve giving them photos to share with friends and then turn around and use it for ads.
Any non-camera / non-photo editing app should never need any permanent access to your library, restricted set or not.
If the choice is between making it effectively impossible for you to give Meta all the messages and emails between us, and making it a trivial decision in a nagging popup, I'd prefer we keep it impossible.
If there was infrastucture to support mutual consent, I'd be more inclined to buy into your premise. But that's not coming any time soon.
As someone who used to use a lot of third party apps for core functionality in Android, I ... like the idea of third party apps taking over some of this stuff. But I don't know if I want Meta to be the one to do it!