All the lackluster AI, VR, and other toys have been wasted efforts though.
That would be tax fraud. Tax-exempt charitable donations from MoFo can't be used for product development by MoCo, a for-profit company.
How, exactly? Excess from Google's money drops?
If their corporate structure is a barrier to using donations for development, I think they need to change it. If "MoFo" can't send money to "MoCo," but I bet the opposite could be made to work. Maybe "MoCo" should gift the browser software and development teams to "MoFo," and pay the Google money (as long as it lasts) to the foundation to license it back to distribute it with search engine-placements, etc.
That strategy only works for browsers that are basically just thin wrappers around Chrome or Webkit, with basically no development cost for the core browser tech and low divergence from those platforms. It's not going to sustain a fully independent browser stack.
But now i would never want to support them. The goodwill is just gone and if you give money to mozilla right now it gets wasted on nonsense, they have so little interest in firefox. I'd rather support any of the forks.
There's no "alternative revenue stream" that would bring in that quantity of money without requiring significant investment that would detract from Firefox engineering, which people would then also whine about endlessly.
It’s not like those alternative streams have been very successful. Feels like they’ve been floundering from project to project for a decade now.
That strategy only works for browsers that are basically just thin wrappers around Chrome or Webkit, with basically no development cost for the core browser tech and low divergence from those platforms. It's not going to sustain a fully independent browser stack.
What if they monetize an aspect of the browser that people will actually pay good money for (something more than Pocket).
Heck even Brave is trying something with its model.
Personally I'd like to see them try to recreate what Scroll were doing a few years ago before the Twitter acquisition destroyed them. They'd have to make it cross-browser though.
Maybe Firefox could release an ad-supported edition?
On Firefox doing ads, you must have missed https://blog.mozilla.org/en/mozilla/mozilla-anonym-raising-t... (Brave post on a related move by Mozilla and Meta at https://brave.com/blog/mozilla-ppa/).
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42380899
We talked to Tony Haile and Scroll before they exited. I asked him how selling (enterprise pre-sales and sales) to publishers was going. Tony said "it's like stabbing yourself in the eye a different way each day".
Publishers do not want to share subscriber data, period full stop. They also hate ad blockers. For Brave, we had to make a primal choice: user-first means blocking ads and trackers, not trying to serve publishers too. House divided will fall, and this kind of conflict of interest between fake blockers who sell whitelisting or otherwise cater to big publishers has hurt Eyeo GmbH among others famous cases.
Firefox is developed by Mozilla Corporation, a for-profit.
https://blog.mozilla.org/blogarchive/blog/2021/01/08/we-need...
Calling for algorithm and advertising transparency should not be controversial.
It's not. You just picked the least controversial one.
> Turn on by default the tools to amplify factual voices over disinformation.
I don't care what they define as factual. Give me what I look for, not what I did not look for.
You would take issue with a note that says "FYI that's not true at all, here are videos explaining that"?