Maybe we need a new term for excessive killing of civilians but short of trying to wipe out a whole people.
Maybe we need a new term for excessive killing of civilians but short of trying to wipe out a whole people.
If you allow I would like to rephrase your conclusion differently
> The Nazis committed genocide but so did the USA, the USSR, the CCCP so they should not act all high and mighty as a paragon of morality.
It was a "good genocide"
Perhaps in its record week. But "each week", no. In fact its average was 4-5k per week.
Meanwhile, it is unlikely that the Dresden bombing (occuring as it did just 3 months before the end of the war, after Auschwitz and nearly all the other camps in the East had been liberated) did much of anything to hasten the end of the war, let alone to mitigate any further atrocities.
That's why it gets so much attention. From just the sheer senselessness of it.
You are at war with Nazi Germany and you're doing everything in your power to bring the war to a close and in war sometimes your attacks aren't as effective as you'd like.
But if you want just say that this investigation is just all retarded, then that's your right I guess.
>It was a "good genocide"
How good could it get?
I worked with a German machinist from there who had experienced it at the time.
He didn't think it was so good, and it was a very long time afterwards. Me neither the more I knew.
Just doing his job back when he was a teenager, like I was when we were doing our project.
Not really sure even then if we were contributing to a military device or not.
But it's a high-tech factory, so.
And he was one of the lucky survivors.
Think how everybody else felt.
As they were dying.
They were his friends and co-workers.
Who shared their last words with him. They hated America worse than ever. Not easy to forget.
But he was still able to forgive the average American, including me, and build real friendship.
I even played in his polka band a little.
Would still have the sheet music if it wasn't for a damn hurricane.
I don't think that follows. In terms of implying the "so they're all basically the same, and the distinction doesn't really matter" part. On its own terms, the definition just doesn't do that.
Granted, some (many) people might think that way, but I think that's a subset of the broader problem of people being hopelessly caught up in muddled thinking patterns generally, these days.
Maybe we need a new term for excessive killing of civilians but short of trying to wipe out a whole people.
"Partial genocide," "smaller-scale", "mini" etc would seem to do the trick. But unfortunately boring language of that sort doesn't trigger people's dopamine levels, and so content discussing recent events in these more measured tones doesn't get promoted and shared as often.
(BTW, the genocide definition under discussion refers not just to "excessive" killings of civilians, but the specific targeting of civilians of a particular group. If the Allies had only targeted military facilities, even with the greatly more imprecise munitions in use at the time, then it would be much more difficult to say that these bombings were "genocidal". It's the fact that the Allies deliberately targeted residential areas, at a massive scale and with the specific intent of spreading terror in the civilian population, which made these bombings arguably genocidal).