This strikes me as one of those gasoline on the fire suggestions. Made me laugh though! I never get perspectives like this anywhere but HN.
I think self interest being what it is, easier evictions would raise rents.
I am a landlord in a place which is liberal. I will keep my place vacant for months against a mountain of applications until I find someone which I feel comfortable with signing a lease (that bar is HIGH). My place is dirt cheap, I have 3% interest on a place I bought after real estate crash and I only charge enough to cover my mortgage and condo fees (could easily charge additional $1.5k/month). I would be 100% more open to signing a lease with someone who needs an afforable place A LOT more than my current and former tenants but with the present laws I have to deal with there is absolutely no way that will ever happen
That said, you're saying that you could charge 1.5k more for the place, but don't because you value other qualities in a tenant more, right?
On mass, I'd bet dollars and donuts that what we'd find is people being evicted, or threatened with eviction, in order to raise rents. Situations like "property values have gone up 10% this year and I was too low to begin with. they've got 6 months left on their lease, but if I evict them I bet I have more cache to keep the deposit and I can ~fix my prices~. Business!"
Maybe your principles wouldn't have you do that, but people statistically make self interested decisions like that more often than compassionate ones.
Balance compassion for self and others oughta be the guide.
what you are saying though is a core problem with writing sensible laws, if they are landlord-leaning the landlords will be evicting left and right to make a few extra bucks. if they are tenant-leaning you get families moving from minnesota do east coast that pay sec deposit and first month’s rent and then live in your place for 18 months without possibility of eviction (some covid laws are still in place…)
And yet, despite the complaints, the evidence says otherwise: There is no shortage of landlords. Property is in very high demand - prices are extreme.
There could be a shortage of rental property - oh that’s exactly what the article is talking about.
This should be illegal.
If you want zero effort assets to put your money into, then real-estate really is not you.
This behavior is highly immoral.
I think I like this suggestion more. If that law were passed tomorrow a lot of landlords would want out of the business. Flooding the market with cheap housing seems more likely to reduce homelessness than making it easier to evict tenants.
Oh, this is already what happens.
Also, I’m not sure why people continuously believe that getting rid of property owners will somehow be good for renters, or that the price would be reduced to an amount where poor people can buy it. Empirically never has happened.
Not at all? Not a single landlord would want out of the business? If you couldn't even evict if somebody never paid a single dime of rent, I think that would cascade and destroy the whole industry. An extreme measure that I didn't suggest, you did.
> I’m not sure why people continuously believe that getting rid of property owners will somehow be good for renters.
I don't want to get rid of property owners. I inherently believe it's better to own a home than rent. I do believe converting renters into home owners is good for the ex-renter.
> Renter, property owner. We're all people.
So yes, making it hard to evict people reduces the supply of rental housing and that will raise rents and increase homelessness.