That said, you're saying that you could charge 1.5k more for the place, but don't because you value other qualities in a tenant more, right?
On mass, I'd bet dollars and donuts that what we'd find is people being evicted, or threatened with eviction, in order to raise rents. Situations like "property values have gone up 10% this year and I was too low to begin with. they've got 6 months left on their lease, but if I evict them I bet I have more cache to keep the deposit and I can ~fix my prices~. Business!"
Maybe your principles wouldn't have you do that, but people statistically make self interested decisions like that more often than compassionate ones.
Balance compassion for self and others oughta be the guide.