5G NR-U: Bringing the power of 5G to unlicensed spectrum globally
qualcomm.com
qualcomm.com
Problem 1 is that getting access to spectrum is a pain. And if you are the kind of enterprise prepared to go cellular, you're also the kind of enterprise where your network absolutely needs to work all the time. So your spectrum access needs to be guaranteed, which is not something that you can easily get today (eg CBRS in the US). The alternative is that you get a little chunk from your local mobile operator, but dealing with an MNO is absolutely miserable for enterprises.
Problem 2 is that wifi is not standing still. Wifi 6E and 7 are picking up juicy lessons from the cellular world such as preemptive handover between access points as the client moves around. Wifi chipsets are dirt cheap compared to cellular ones so the cost of devices is lower, and sometimes good enough is better than best.
Problem 3 is that big enterprises like to have consistent BOMs across all operating entities. To my mind, the only bands that can be used on equipment all over the world with no meaningful roadblocks are those that run in the ISM bands, eg the wifi bands and the (?)850Mhz one used by industrial gear. So qualcomm are trying to bring 5G to a new spectrum band that isnt universal and where there is already a cheaper solution. Gonna be an uphill struggle.
By the way, there are better WiFi APs. Ruckus’ APs have software configurable antennas that are rather amazing at improving SNR. It works by becoming a semi-directional antenna by choosing an appropriate antenna pattern. This technique is in addition to the 802.11 standard’s beam forming. I have had excellent results with them in my home after keeping the 2.4GHz channels widths at 20MHz and disabling the DFS 5GHz bands.
Maybe the intent is to make it like wifi but it read much more like a telco sell. Or perhaps it's the commoditisation of iot radio layers for manufacturing?
These unlicensed frequencies combine the benefits of Wi-Fi and 5G together.
You have to buy your own base station. Its for IoT, factory automation, home use. 5G small cell architecture.
I remember hearing that some conference at some point did its own 4G network with its own SIM cards. They had gotten permission to use licensed spectrum for the duration of the event. Unfortunately, I do not remember which conference. If I did, I would look at what they said about how they got the SIM cards for it.
If you only need Wifi, you should not invent reasons not to get 5G station.
There are actually the same legal frameworks and products for LTE as well; you can request quotes for an EPC installed on a mini PC and mini eNB in white plastic enclosures with requisite FCC labels. Though, cost and performance were not highly competitive relative to Wi-Fi. Starting from couple thousands of dollars or so.
LTE-U has already existed since 2018, so this announcement is mostly saying they've worked out the details for a 5G version. This includes interop with LTE and the regulatory stuff.
Once enough boomers die off, and the number of VHF TV watchers drops to near zero, what would this band be useful for, if reallocated for a purpose or just unlicensed?
We should be pro OTA services not against.
It wouldnt be too useful for high speed bidirectional communications though because the signals travel well and thus it would be difficult to pack stations densely.
Or they'll keep VHF TV on. I think the latter is arguably more useful.