Can it avoid dark patterns? If it can't, then it's not a solution to anything. It's more like an additional problem. It also opens the door to the concept of dark agents (hey, this bot _always_ installs the Altavista search bar).
Can it avoid dark patterns? If it can't, then it's not a solution to anything. It's more like an additional problem. It also opens the door to the concept of dark agents (hey, this bot _always_ installs the Altavista search bar).
What do you think is going to happen if an AI system which avoids current dark patterns starts being widespread? Bad actors aren’t going to shrug their shoulders and stop, they’re just going to make systems which trick those AIs. Adapting a dark pattern is significantly faster and more cost effective than training a new AI to bypass those new approaches.
Dark patterns work because human psychology is fairly homogeneous. It’s possible that AI will be similar, but I suspect that won’t be the case.
There is a vastly greater diversity of humans than AI implementations. It is delusional to think the current crop AI, trained on human behaviour and interactions, won’t be able to be tricked just as easily or even more so, when we’ve been doing it since the start.
And you really think human neuro- and cognitive architecture is more diverse than the many many many different ML architectures? That’s a bold claim. We have wide ML models, and deep, and LORA, a million flavors of transformers and then a million non-transformer architcthres.
I’m very suspicious of your absolute certainty and complete dismissal of contrary opinions.
The problem is: that data has a lot of users under the influence of dark patterns. People shopping in stupid ways, falling for tricks. They probably know this and improved search against some of these patterns in the past. But it's not perfect, right? Search isn't.
Large models fall for tricks all the time, you have to assume the other way around. They will fail, and you can reduce that failure rate, but never zero it.
I'd say no.
Yes, yes they are. A captcha is a simple system which returns a binary pass/fail. A dark pattern plays with your understanding of reality to make you choose what is beneficial to the company at your expense.
AI systems will be gamed to follow dark patterns too.