Chemical reactions deplete nutrients in plant-based drinks
phys.org
phys.org
That language choice alone made me suspect it was conducted by a dairy lobby. But it's the article author who made this decision, rather than the University researchers or funding institutions (which appear to be medical and pharmaceutical R&D firms).
Interesting case study in how writers using ideologically driven language can make their reporting so unclear as to be almost meaningless (there are people who insist on avoiding the word "milk" to describe anything derived from plants, but "plant-based drinks" is such a vague label it can refer to anything from juice to hot chocolate)
So is it the colour what makes a difference?
Also hot chocolate can be made with milk or plant alternative. And it will be a "plant based drink" only for the latter.
In Netherlands there was a case that a company was using word "milk" to market plant based drink. That didn't fly far, they were fined (AFAIR) and they had to stop that practice. Milk (and butter) by definition are animal products. For the same reason peanut butter is called pindakaas - peanut cheese.
The researches were specifically talking about "plant-based milk alternatives", as in "alternatives to milk". Hot chocolate may be a plant-based drink, but it is not a milk alternative. "plant-based milk alternatives" is a very clear label that avoids the debate around calling them milks.
My own opinion is that cow's milk shouldn't be labeled a human food, so I'm fine with "plant milks" and personally just refer to them "milk" in some contexts, but for the sake of packaging and writing for the general public, I think clarity is important, and "oat milk" or "oat-based milk alternative" are both much clearer than "oat juice", especially since commercial products are rarely just one ingredient + water.
For example, you have "soy kefir", "soy yoghurt", and "soymilk", all different things and I don't see a case for "soy juice" being more accurate for soymilk than the other two.
Also you have "coconut water" and "coconut milk" and if we're going to call one of those a juice I certainly wouldn't go with coconut milk.
Designating it as a "milk" or at least a "milk alternative" is useful in indicating what role it might play in cuisine, and calling it a "drink" does not communicate the same thing.
Also, referring to plant milks with the word for "milk" (or local language variant) appears to be a tradition dating back at least 700 years in English (and longer for other languages): https://theliterarycucina.wordpress.com/2018/03/27/medieval_...
But humans drink it?
> "oat milk" or "oat-based milk alternative" are both much clearer than "oat juice"
It doesn't get called "oat juice", it gets called "oat drink".
Calling it a milk when the macronutrients and amino acid composition is entirely not equal to animal milk is the misleading part.
> referring to plant milks with the word for "milk" [...] appears to be a tradition dating back at least 700 years
That is a valid argument.
And I believe it's not just archaic; plant liquids that resemble milk can be referred to as milk in a general meaning, rather than in the strict mammary gland output meaning of milk. But this general definition of milk is still separate from when alternatives to cow's milk are productized.
Recent EU law acts as consumer protection against the misconception that plant-based drinks are nutritionally one-to-one alternatives to cow's milk. While they may be healthy, or even healthier given the right total diet, you can't substitute milk with a plant-based drink and expect the same nutritional value.
By logical extreme, dyed water can be a plant-based milk alternative. And out goes consumer protection.
Humans eat other humans as well. I still think human meat shouldn't be labeled as food. And if you are going to sell animal milk for human consumption, why not just call it "Cow milk", "goat milk", etc. since that would at least indicate the animal that would naturally consume it.
> It doesn't get called "oat juice", it gets called "oat drink".
And Horchata is a rice drink, but it's different from what I would consider rice milk.
> Calling it a milk when the macronutrients and amino acid composition is entirely not equal to animal milk is the misleading part.
I wasn't questioning whether it should be called milk, or even product naming restrictions in a specific country, but the clarity of the author's choice of words for this article on a global platform, and specifically when talking about "plant-based drinks" which again, is a very vague description which encompasses nearly all drinks that aren't animal milk.
Perhaps there's even a cultural bias to my opinion; I don't know how much of the world would find "plant-based drinks" more clear than "plant-based milk alternatives" (though I suspect the vast majority would find the latter clearer). For what it's worth, the study this article is about also used "plant-based milk alternatives".
Again, soy milk and soy kefir would both be "soy drinks". I find "soy milk" or "soy-based milk alternative" much clearer (and I don't see how the latter could be confused with cow milk).
> By logical extreme, dyed water can be a plant-based milk alternative. And out goes consumer protection.
This doesn't follow to me. Assuming it's a plant-based dye I can see more of an argument for calling it a "plant-based drink" than "plant-based milk". Are you saying that "plant-based drink" is intentionally vague so that companies can sell whatever they want as a "plant-based drink"? Or are there actual regulations requiring "X drink" to be what I think of as "X milk"?
No they don’t.
If eating human flesh was an actual tendency in a society civilised enough to discuss food labelling rules, that would be a legitimate comparison and a real concern.
But as it stands, (cow’s) milk gets produced in the millions of gallons, and human meat you still have to find on Craigslist or on the streets of San Francisco.
> I find "soy milk" or "soy-based milk alternative" much clearer
Ironically, it is “milk” (in the texture sense) by definition of not being very clear.
> I don't know how much of the world would find "plant-based drinks" more clear than "plant-based milk alternatives"
Only by assuming a similarity with dairy that is not nutritionally justified.
> Or are there actual regulations requiring "X drink" to be what I think of as "X milk"?
Yes, read my original post. I linked to a 2018 decision by the EU court that forbade this.
Just as a fun heads up on human history, the markers are there that humans have eaten humans globally for several thousand years ...
Funerary cannibalism appears to have been common as a mark of respect and humans developed defences against brain prion diseases .. this came to light when looking into why the Fore people developed Kuru .. they developed a sporadic variation that jumped the guard rails.
In relatively recent recent European history there have been spates of "Corpse Medicine" (worth looking up) in which parts of Egyption mummies were eaten, parts of executed criminals, etc.
Supermarkets are not allowed to call it "soy milk", you have to call it e.g. "soy drink" etc. so you won't confuse it with cow's milk. Some brands challenge this by putting "m!lk" or "not m_lk!" on the packaging, which has been tolerated for years.
https://foodcomplianceinternational.com/industry-insight/new...
Surely the dairy lobby had something to do with it, but it's become mainstream.
"This work was supported by funding from the Novo Nordisk Foundation (grant no. NNF21OC0066330) to MNL, and from “SOCIETÀ ITALIANA DI FARMACOLOGIA (SIF)” to MP. The funding agency had no involvement in the experimental design or interpretation of the results."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novo_Nordisk_Foundation#Role_i...
"Concerns have been raised about the potential influence of the Novo Nordisk Foundation's agenda on the direction of scientific research. Critics express concerns about the potential effect of the foundation's allocation of funds on the diversity of research topics and perspectives within the Danish scientific community,[36] as it tends to prioritize projects that align with its strategic goals.[37]"
Some degree of lactose intolerance and longer shelf life after opening are other likely reasons.
And it is frustrating to demonize long shelf life techniques without acknowledging how safe they make the food, as well.
Did they put the decimal in the wrong place? It should be ~34g for milk....
EDIT: The study probably means mg/100mL right?
Also cow milk is full of hormones and inflammatory substances and most humans are not adapted to drink it.
> cow's milk used in the study contains 3.4 grams of protein per liter, whereas eight of the 10 plant-based drinks analyzed contained between 0.4 and 1.1 grams of protein.
3g/liter won't help people get enough protein. Neither will most plant milks, but cow milk has saturated fat that contributes to LDL cholesterol and diabetes and has a dense caloric content
> The levels of essential amino acids were lower in all plant-based drinks.
This is virtually the same thing as lower protein levels.
> seven out of 10 plant-based drinks contained more sugar than cow's milk.
So, don't buy the plant milk that has sugar added!
> The compound was measured at levels so low that it poses no danger.
ok.
> Both are reactive substances that could potentially be harmful to human health when present in high concentrations, although this is not the case here
ok.
Protip: drink flaxmilk! it has high protein, low calories, and high good fat content! protein content is the same as 1.5% milk
Almond milk is mostly just water. so while it doesn't have much beneficial, it has less harmful stuff () than cow milk
() sat fat, IGF-1 and other hormones, acne-causing, allergic to large % of world, possible (though not conclusive!) prostrate and ovarian cancer