Yet even in oil soaked Texas, renewables account for most new capacity being added to their electrical grid. Why? It's cheaper. Simple economics.
This is the current reality that you might want to check in on.
Preytending that renewables are winning based purely on economics is disingenuous. If it were true, things like this would be unnecessary:
https://apnews.com/united-states-presidential-election-9dfb1...
So even when the right has control of a large oil soaked state like Texas for decades, it's still all the left's fault?
Distort reality much?
The end of fossil fuels is inevitable. The supply is limited. "Drill baby drill" will only reach the end faster and cause more environmental damage for your kids to deal with.
This is the line Texan anti-renewable lobbyists are coming out with [1].
[1] https://www.theenergyalliance.com/research/the-end-of-texas-...
Texas is still building gas generators [1][2].
Renewables are cheaper, but on the margin. Their production remains low, and despite massive growth, won't going to rival whole-grid growth for at least a decade. (Growth + replacement takes us into the 2040s.) That means we need other power sources for decades to come. America went with gas, which makes sense–we have lots of it. China with coal for the same reason. (Europe, also gas, which doesn’t make sense, but they don’t want to do coal or nuclear and don't seem to be deeply thinking about this.)
In the long run we’ll probably be all solar with marginal wind, hydro and experimental sources. That will not happen in our lifetimes. Texas and Germany are prime examples of why simplifying our grid’s future to a single source is not only economically infeasible but also politically self defeating.
[1] https://www.power-eng.com/gas/calpine-affirms-plan-to-build-...
[2] https://www.powermag.com/new-gas-fired-power-plants-proposed...
In Germany this has been a major problem for many companies that invested to be greener and the costs were huge. It doesn't matter that 1kwh costs 10 cents less when you need to invest 100 millions to change your infrastructure.
- https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/konjunktur/insolvenzen-...
- https://www.tagesspiegel.de/wirtschaft/hohe-zinsen-und-energ...
- https://www.tagesspiegel.de/wirtschaft/hohe-energiekosten-li...
Not sure if VW, Bosch, Thyssenkrupp count, but they have been in the news for a year now...
- https://www.dw.com/en/is-german-industry-migrating-to-the-us...
- https://www.ft.com/content/bca7837a-6ac4-4ed1-ab73-18fbdfa5f...
- https://fortune.com/europe/2024/02/19/german-companies-pouri...
That's true, they didn't shut down the factories yet, they are just firing thousands of people and opening up / investing in the US :)
Honestly I find the goal of 100% renewables awesome. But take it easy, with Merkel we reached a very high percentage in a steady way - why not to proceed like that instead of getting crazy....
https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/themen/klima-energie/erneuerb...
Neither of them can be reached with coal/gas/other fossil fuels. In addition, having 100% renewables means that you have an entire society ready for it - from infra to consumers.
So, no, that's for me in no way an implementation detail like "I am just swapping A with B" otherwise I am pretty damn sure we could stop everything we're doing and mount solar panels everywhere to reach 100% renewables.
In principle I understand what you were trying to say, but I don't agree on the premise that they are just an implementation detail.
The better term would be 'sustainable'. What you want is to have 'sustainable' near zero emission, near zero Co2, safe energy production.
Renewables also misleading because by definition hunting wales for oil is 'renewable' but nobody would consider that 'sustainable'.
So to write legislation with a narrow viewpoint of 'renewable' as the goal, rather then the goal being reducing on emission and CO2, you are shooting yourself in the foot from the jump.
However, there is a very strong correlation between reaching those targets and the broad/accepted definition of renewables. Again, I understand you're trying to be more precise and all that, but in the broader language the connection is "renewables = reduction of CO2 in a sustainable way with solar panels, wind, etc etc".
EDIT: ok, I forgot, there would be the nuclear energy as well to reduce CO2, which is not really renewable (although most of it can be recycled it seems). You were right. I would still prefer 100% renewable (and have no burning fuels at all) but I would be happy to have a mix of renewable and nuclear to reduce emissions and still keep companies up and running (=cheap electricity).