If I ask a 5yo "42 * 21 equals...?" and the kid replies with a random number, say, "882", and gets it right, it does not mean that the kid knows what multiplication is or how it works.
If I ask a 5yo "42 * 21 equals...?" and the kid replies with a random number, say, "882", and gets it right, it does not mean that the kid knows what multiplication is or how it works.
I'm not arguing for or against anything specifically, I just want to note that in practice I assume that to the LLM it's just a bunch of repeating prompts with the entire convo, and after outputting special 'signifier' tokens, the llm just suddenly gets a prompt that has the results of the program that was executed in an environment. for all we know various prompts were involved in setting up that environment too, but I suspect not.
The execution of that expression is being carried out by a fundamentally separate set of algorithms, which do not have the same strengths or weaknesses.