Male and female brains are wired differently
earth.com
earth.com
It does link a few papers, but I assume those papers are only a tiny fraction of the research being done.
I thought the same and was irritated that it talks about the study without linking to it whereas at the same time providing several other links (irrelevant to me). Finally, they did it at the very bottom.
So basically, for a casual reader, they discuss the main findings and explain their significance whereas the study just present the facts. On HN, we could just post the link to the study I guess, but for the general public it makes sense to explain what the white matter is etc.
It does, however, suggest that transgender identities could have a biological basis. Studies already hint that trans people have brains more like their gender than their sex. It's nowhere near giving us a diagnostic tool, but there's reason to think that it's not a fad or meme or whatever else anti-trans activists are claiming this week.
Some trans people think of transgender as an intersex condition. I'm not sure the studies really justify that yet, but it's worth looking into. It's not necessary to have a biological basis to justify their identity, but it would shortcut a lot of useless arguments.
It turned out that these were brain differences relating to homosexuality. Later studies that controlled for sexuality (that is, by including both same-sex and opposite-sex attracted transsexuals in the cohort) couldn't replicate the earlier findings of sexually dimorphic brain structures being associated with transsexuality itself.
Instead, researchers found functional differences in brain regions associated with bodily perception, similar to what is seen in body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) patients. Which I think is a more interesting finding, perhaps suggesting that gender dysphoria is a subtype of BDD, or at least has some neurological commonality.
In the aggregate men are better at math, but my wife is better at it than 99.9% of men.
> Male newborns generally have more white matter in their brains.
Yet again. This is trash.
You can look at the charts, the distributions clearly overlap a lot, but there are also clear differences. Can't say what the implications are, if any, this is up to research to figure out.
PS: it would be very interesting to study brains in transexual people to see if any of those patterns are confirmed and how.
The only point of this type of research is to go with girlbrain ideology. Otherwise they'd be studying functional differences between people with different ratios of white matter and grey matter, and not obsessing about sex.
Instead, what they're doing is looking at any statistical differences that they can find between men and women, and assigning "differences" in the female direction with stereotypes about girls. Typical:
> You may know some boys who are very sensitive, immensely talkative about feelings, and just generally don’t seem to fit the “boy” way of doing things. As with all gender differences, no one way of doing things is better or worse.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/hope-relationships/2...
Girlbrain and the law of averages as a defense against accusations of misogyny. The standard cocktail.
Research on differences between sexes is useful and often needed for providing tailored health services and even for fighting prejudices or reducing systematic biases in society. Pretending we are all the same doesn't help anybody.
On the opposite - this is factual presentation of the data from the study that contains substantial overlap as clearly stated in the study itself. What is so trashy about it?
---
If you have been in a large annoying chat group with a large number of active women, you will quickly see how they broadly value empathy over logic. And just forget about expecting nuanced systemization from them; it will never happen.
This has risks for juries.