There is a psychology paper waiting to be written about humans perceiving intellect as the ability to communicate knowledge convincingly and thus being amazed by LLMs. I’m by no means immune to it
Its been a long time since i've been amazed by an HN comment in a positive way. This is a really, really good way of putting it. I'd go further: humans are willing to forgive shockingly grievous intellectual crimes (c.f.: hallucination, dangerous reasoning errors, etc.) if they are clearly communicated in the way you describe.