HN likes to blame safetyism or the "perception of crime" as if crime isn't real. The answer is that big cities in the US and Western Europe have changed in the past 20-30 years. There has been a real increase in free-range mentally deranged homeless. And a parallel increase in "cultural diversity" via immigration, leading to a lower trust environment all around. It may be a low probability event for a homeless lunatic to scream at your child or worse, or for your kid to wander into the wrong neighborhood, but parents don't want their kids exposed to that crap. Who would? Meanwhile, affluent parents have fewer children to spare and very thin communities to watch out for kids in general. The CPS laws penalizing more traditional parenting certainly don't help things.