AI Coding Is Based on a Faulty Premise
articles.pragdave.me
articles.pragdave.me
[1] Yes of course there are some cases where the code is the hard part. The majority of software however that is not the case.
There are impossible problems that cannot be solved by computers, but through changing the structure/requirements we can make many of those problems possible to solve.
The problem with AI is it makes the value of labor worthless at the early stages of a generational pipeline of professionals.
If there is no economic benefit, the best and brightest leave the field for better returns on investment. If no one enters the beginning, no one makes it to the end. Intermediate professionals in their first decade stop existing, Senior level professionals die off from old age. The only people end up being left are those who cannot pivot, which is the bottom 50-60% who aren't particularly competent but can scrape by if they work alongside competent people.
Then there is also the societal failures that this will rapidly accelerate, where production will inevitably cease from chaos, and half the world starves.
AI is worse than pandora's box. Its a proverbial devil's pleasure palace, where you get everything you want in the short term, and self-annihilate in the long term (if you fall prey to its initial allure).
So from that perspective it makes sense why companies would rush to replace pesky engineers asking for how something should be written. But they're piling on technical debt AND no one even understands the system! And as you add more technical debt the system context gets larger which means whatever LLM you're using can grab less and less of it.
It's madness created by idiots that have no clue what they're doing. I'm glad I'm over the experience hump so when the shit hits the fan and flies into the face of these companies I can demand a premium. But they're going to screw over an entire generation of entry level software engineers along the way.
The inherent assumption precludes the possibility that organized production fails (including food), and with it goes the ability to survive. If exchange becomes impossible because of imbalances created by such tools alongside moneyprinting (which is very likely), then its pretty much over for everyone.
All efficient methods of production today depend on brittle non-resilient supply chains. Food production fails back to pre-industrial methods and Malthusian ecological overshoot reversion ensues, (i.e. half the world population dies because there isn't enough food to sustain).
AI fundamentally destroys the foundations of civilized rational society.
Couple the chaotic disruption of this with a debt trap caused by runaway money printing and you can easily get cascading failures that cause production failures.
Are you familiar with Thomas Malthus?
Here's an overview albeit very simple.
https://www.resilience.org/stories/2005-03-15/overshoot-nuts...
Its flawed to assume you and everyone else can continue to follow a business as usual approach anymore. We already reached the limits of growth. There is very little time before a fall.
You should be aware that there is no experience hump that will make these things safe. I've a decade of direct IT experience at the principal engineer/admin level, and been out of work for two years now; I'm retraining to HVAC installation now since no ones hiring.
What I'm doing is what happens to the most competent people when there is no work to be had. Once I'm in HVAC, I may play around on side projects in IT, but I wouldn't subject myself to more torture by being dependent on my IT experience.
What happens in IT first, later happens broadly. IT is a labor multiplier for everyone else. When labor value of skilled work hits 0 broadly, everything collapses.
If you can't find legitimate positions because they all look legitimate, and you never make it to the interview (1:1000 conversion ratio), it won't matter how much you know or how much direct experience you have.
I'm seriously looking at securing off-grid food options, and the necessary people/skills to ensure it can't be stolen.
Non-reserve debt issuance and money printing will continue driving this trend until food production collapses, then half the global population starves. Its the problem with positive feedback systems. They runaway, and cascade towards failures.
The article you posted is a secondary effect. It's like saying that writing in math lingo "conveys a false sense of intelligence". Sure but that's not the point and it's mostly a projection of the listener's insecurity and lack of familiarity with the language anyway.
Just like you can map English to the language you use at work. You had to learn the language first, or you wouldn't have internalized its grammar and semantics.
I'd rather get a complex spec in English than in pseudocode. But I'm still going to write the code in C# or whatever.
Communication by words and language in general is the sharing of meaning. At one point, each word had a distinct and unique meaning, that may have depended on context, but it always followed rational principles in the definition.
This is no longer the case. Words have been corrupted so that by definition (formal or informal/spoken), they may have two potentially contradictory meanings. Fallacy and other deceit then creep in, and without a direct unique and non-contradictory definition, you can't communicate anything; even if it sounds like communication (it isn't when meaning isn't shared).