That doest mean that there isn't plenty of room for more centralized civil protections against negligence and recklessness.
That doest mean that there isn't plenty of room for more centralized civil protections against negligence and recklessness.
Corporations are giant responsibility diffusion machines and more often than not they stumble into illegal activity rather than internally commit to it. Hence, they are not acting intentionally. Also relevant is my assertion that this bumbling illegal behavior also needs better enforcement - it's just civil in nature and not criminal.
You still have the problem of punishing diffuse guilt. The correct answer is fines. Massive fines, potentially to the point of bankruptcy. We don't like to do that, however, because corporations have many stakeholders who may not deserve punishment, e.g. employees.
There's countless ways around the issue of "average" employees being punished. E.g. hard caps on top employee compensation for X years. Bans on dividends.
Forced stock dilution, now that's a solid one. Create extra shares equivalent to 20% of market cap, given to the government who sells them on the open market.
I'm sure there's holes in these but plenty of smarter people than me who can easily make them watertight.
How do either of these help an employee of a company that was just poofed?
> there's holes in these but plenty of smarter people than me who can easily make them watertight
No. There aren't. Both the caps you proposed--capping dividends and salary--have known workarounds. Stock buybacks exist because they're more tax efficient than dividends. Health insurance is tied to employment because in WWII the U.S. government capped wages.
There is really one solution to corporate malfeasance: criminaly prosecuting where you have evidence of individual criminality and massive fines in every other case. We bankrupted our automakers without hurting their jobs. That's actually less intrusive than trying to fuck with their capital structure by e.g. banning dividends, which just incentivises leverage.
Corporations are hierarchical.
> however, because corporations have many stakeholders who may not deserve punishment, e.g. employees.
Hiding behind the employees. The ones with the least stake in the company. That’s a classic.
They might have their two weeks notice. What else? “There might be no other jobs around?”
Class collaboration is a lie.
"Let them eat cake" isn't a winning pitch when it's your job on the line.
No, I'm pointing out the real limitations on the types of punishments that folks--typically on the left, with good intentions but breathlessly naively--like to propose. Ignoring the board doesn't make you a smarter player.
I'm then pointing out the option that works within those limitations to exact tremendous justice. The option that when it comes up, anyone in its crosshairs will immediately start pointing to hare-brained schemes like a "corporate death penalty" to get out of. Massive. Fines.
(For those who prefer jail time to fines, do you really thing Bytedance's CZ would trade his 6 months in jail for the tens of billions he's personally walked away with?)
You're again reinventing corporate fines in a way that makes them problematic. You've not only dissolved limited liability, which makes investing in equities a rich man's game, you're proposing going after tens if not hundres of millions of Americans if a single Fortune 500 breaks a law. That's mechanically impossible.
> Next time it is sold the sale price goes toward the fine. And so does any dividend paid.
Poor people pay the fine. Rich borrow against their shares.
None of these problems exist with massive fines. None of them add anything, procedurraly or punitively, over massive fines. The idea that shareholders are going to do legal scrutiny when many professional investors barely read public filings is laughable. Re-inventing fines is rolling your own legal system when we have centuries of good law to rely on deriving from corporations suing each other.
Those employees disagree with you and they vote. Every district has large employers whose employees would, as a voting bloc, flip a primary or even general election.
Americans do. But every time it comes up, the discussion gets derailed with these ancilliary ideas. Just look at this thread. Fines are old and boring.
> the large fines aren't assessed because those in the position to be fined also as a rule have more influence over the system
There is also the practical matter of the power to levy large fines being, itself, immensely powerful. You don't want to create a fine czar only to lose control of them in a term or two.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo_cross-selling_scan...
The incentives align to encourage executives to commit crimes in service of short-term gains — even in the extreme case of Wells Fargo, Carrie Tolstedt and John Stumpf have both avoided prison time and ended up money ahead to the tune of tens of millions of dollars, even after clawbacks and fines.
Not only shouldn't intent matter, we should assume the worst. Whether assuming the worst is a workable enforcement regime, I don't know — but it most accurately models a reality where the most rational behavior for executives is indifference to the law.
The problem is to prove that something is done intentional, on a "corporate level", whatever that means in the given case. Imagine having a law where breaking it would mean that the business have to shutdown. A competitor could pay off someone inside the company to break the law deliberately to have the legal system remove competition.
Yknow maybe the modern day requires rethinking of some regulations regarding corporations.