BTW if anyone is thinking of flagging this submission for being political, I request you do a search for previous stories including 'Guantanamo' and realize that it has been considered a worthy topic of discussion on HN pretty much since its inception.
1. The Supreme Court has already ruled that anyone held there has all the rights they would have if they were held in a jail in the continental US.
2. It would (probably) put the US in violation of their lease with Cuba, who would immediately cancel it - something they’ve wanted to do for 70+ years but previously had no legal method of accomplishing.
3. The weather is fabulous this time of year.
Your point 3 is needlessly idiotic.
Rest assured that political dissidents (tagged as "antifa") will be there before long. After that... watch for smokestacks.