Hacker News Reader

What's a "reasonable price"?

A penny taken off the monthly cost of Internet access by fiat is a penny subsidy granted to Internet service customers.

In a competitive market for Internet service, providers can't gouge customers because they'd lose to competitors that didn't.

You are making a stronger argument against local service cable, copper loop and RF monopolies than you are against the libertarian opposition to net neutrality.

View on HN

That is exactly the point though. Since there AREN'T enough competitors, the free market does not work. BEING a competitor means laying cable, getting right-of-ways, getting other permissions from local government, etc. It is not something where several competitors will spring up offering better service and/or better price when one bad actor decides to disallow skype on their network for instance.

When the market fails to provide a fix, the government should step in to keep the public from being at the mercy of greedy monopolies.

It's also very difficult to start a new car company. But we don't have "car neutrality".

Reply on news.ycombinator.com