How do we make sure that minorities and women get the same fair chance at NSF grants as white men, when white men are making most of the decisions? How do we make sure we're funding science that helps everyone, not just those who make the highest decisions?
DEI initiatives are reasonable way to increase the likelihood that a minority is considered for a job and not passed over by endemic racism.
Are they though? Racism is still wrong even when you use it for what you consider worthy goals.
DEI is trying to apply a corrective lens to racism; it says (I'm paraphrasing) to make a conscious effort to include more black people in your search for employees. If you have two equal candidates, maybe consider hiring the black person as a correction for the times they don't get hired.
I'll give what I consider to be a positive experience with DEI. A while back my company was hiring an engineer and a woman candidate did poorly on her phone screen. Normally we didn't bring in candidates who did poorly but the hiring manager decided that we didn't have enough woman engineers and brought in the candidate for interviews anyway. I was one of the interviewers and the woman was one of the best interviews I ever conducted. We eventually hired her and she was one of the smartest coworkers I ever had.
In retrospect she did poorly on the phone screen because English was her third language. Was it unfair that she got a second chance when a male candidate wouldn't? Maybe, but the entire field of software engineering is unfair against women and this was one action to help level it.
We can all hope for a day we don't need DEI to give everyone an equal chance but that is not this day.
[0] - https://www.npr.org/2024/04/11/1243713272/resume-bias-study-...
It's amusing how much Democrats bitch and moan when Republicans finally put an end to their racist policies.
First time was with Abraham Lincoln. Now this.
Nothing ever changes.