This hinges on the government defining Bitcoin as "property" which is distinct from "money". They normally assert that only US currency is "money". As such, any property that changes value (i.e. Bitcoin) is subject to capital gains tax.
So if spenders of Bitcoin don't mind filing a separate tax form for every Bitcoin transaction, then Bitcoin fixes this. Otherwise, not so much.
Bitcoin does fix the problem in the sense it is obviously property. But that doesn't solve much.
Citizen: I don't have $50,000
Government: You have $50,000 worth of bonds and securities
Citizen: That's property. I demand a jury trial by my peers.
Government: <crickets>
Where's the incentive for me to stop hitting you with a hose? Maybe a few more wallets will shake loose. And if not, oh well.
Really? It's digital. It can be accessed anywhere. You just force the person to give it to you. Why do you think crypto executives are such popular K&R targets?
Crypto is constantly being seized. And unlike cash, you can't publicly taint every account that interacts with the dirty money.
People use dirty bills all the time with no issue, too. I need to look up who our background check provider is, but I've seen people flagged as a high risk (twice in client onboarding, once in a deal, once in an employment context) due to a known or probably-known wallet having a high frequency of high-risk transactions. That's, put simply, not visibility I have into anyone's bank account.
In two of the cases we added safeguards (at client and counterparty's cost) and in two I declined to proceed.
Indeed. But cash is easier to seize: you just need to know where it's stashed vs crypto where you need to know where it's stashed + know a secret password/pin that may only exist inside someone's head. And even if you find something that might look like a crypto wallet, you may not even be able to verify that it is one or what it contains.
> I need to look up who our background check provider is, but I've seen people flagged as a high risk (twice in client onboarding, once in a deal, once in an employment context) due to a known or probably-known wallet having a high frequency of high-risk transactions. That's, put simply, not visibility I have into anyone's bank account.
That's just an overzealous policy that some financial institutions (aka AML "obliged entities") voluntarily decide to subject themselves to. Pretty much no one does such background checks for p2p and commercial transactions.
It’s a watered-down version of the stuff every bank uses. Hell, my small-town bank does this when screening mortgage applications.