Comment by Cieric | Hacker News Reader

Comment by Cieric | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

After a bunch of testing and looking around I think I should actually change my statement. GPUs do offer IEEE floating point compliance by default, but don't strictly adhere to it. Multiple optimizations that can be applied by the driver developers can massively effect the floating point accuracy.

This is all kind of on the assumption that the accuracy of floating point multiplication and division is in the IEEE spec, I was told before that it was but searching now I can't seem to find it one way or the other.

I believe one of the optimizations done by nvidia is to drop f32 variables down to f16 in a shader. Which would technically break the accuracy requirement (as before if it exists). I don't have anything I can offer as proof of that due to NDA sadly though. I will note that most of my testing and work is done in PIX for Windows, and most don't have anti-cheat so they're easy to capture.

What shaders (presumably GLSL & HLSL) do precision wise isn’t an IEEE compliance issue, it’s either a DX/Vulkan spec issue, OR a user compiler settings issue. Dropping compliance is and should be allowed when the code asks for it. This is why GLSL has lowp, mediump, and highp settings. I think all GPUs are IEEE compliant and have been for a long time.

I agree on the dropping compliance when asked for aspect, the problem I'm referring to more is the driver dropping compliance without the game asking for it. If the underlying system can randomly drop compliance when ever it thinks it's fine without telling the user and without the user asking, I would not consider that compliant.

That is fair, if true. But I’m very skeptical any modern drivers are dropping compliance without being asked. The one possibility I could buy is that you ran into a case of someone having dropped precision intentionally in a specific game in order to “optimize” a shader. Otherwise, precision and IEEE compliance is the prerogative of the compiler. The compiler is sometimes in the driver, but it never decides on it’s own what precision to use, it uses either default or explicit precision settings. The only reason it would not produce IEEE compliant code is if it was being asked to.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com