Hacker News Reader

Comment by dasht | Hacker News Reader

To avoid building in a dependency on DNS does not require that the identity system problem be fully solved, first. It only requires ensuring a good abstraction barrier before too much code propagates that depends directly on DNS. For example, perhaps, URIs.

View on HN

Why can't the usernames be like email addresses?

  send email to username@example.net
    => lookup example.net
    => pull MX record
    => route email to example.com

Looks like a SRV record[1] could be used for this.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SRV_record

"Why can't the usernames be like email addresses?" [in the sense of querying DNS to find them].

In this context we're talking about what it takes to avoid relying on DNS (because DNS is a centralized, highly politicized system). Your solution would still rely on DNS.

A system which relies on DNS, but in which anyone can setup a node seems better than a system that relies on DNS but only has one centralized node (Twitter), no?

In a truly decentralized system, you're not going to be able to have readable unique names without collisions. Why? What happens when the network splits, then people on either side of the split setup the same username. How do you rectify this when the network rejoins? How do you know that the network has split vs. a node going offline (if you wanted to do something like shut down new usernames until the network was whole again)?

"A system which relies on DNS, but in which anyone can setup a node seems better than a system that relies on DNS but only has one centralized node (Twitter), no?"

The concern here is that whoever is currently leasing the domain name has authority over users' identities. A better system would let users own their identities outright.

"In a truly decentralized system, you're not going to be able to have readable unique names without collisions. Why? [....]"

This is a well explored topic. A good place to start might be to look up "Zooko's Triangle" and then go forward from there towards various ways people have figured out to deal with such problems. (Zooko's wasn't the last word.)

Is the webfinger protocol [1] like email addresses in the way you're thinking of?

[1] - https://code.google.com/p/webfinger/wiki/WebFingerProtocol

Reply on news.ycombinator.com