That said, I think that the ‘fire them all and let God sort them out’ strategy has a rational economic angle that journalists miss. The cost of all that headcount while you have slow change management vs just fucking around and finding out who’s actually necessary in a corporate setting can make sense, I think. Especially when teams are well entrenched.
Journalists dunk on some CEO who had to rehire five people they needed, the CFO is happy to pay them double + a signing bonus, because the 95 other salaries, management overhead, and presumably political impact of that team is gone.
I’m also of the opinion that even if it may be desirable to some to reset certain programs, that this method won’t translate to government very well; in particular my friends who are federal employees have communicated to me that they are very unused to this sort of treatment, and it’s extremely upsetting — that sort of experience en masse can have huge decades-long impacts in a complex system like the US Federal government.