I've been on HN for a while, I saw the previous hype cycles. I have no doubt we'll see a Zig hype cycle as well.
One of the reasons Rust succeeded, especially in CLI was
1. Low fixed memory overhead (compared to most popular VM based language - Python, Ruby, Java).
2. Startup time is nearly instantaneous, compared to the same languages. Don't have to wait 50-100ms or so just to start executing code.
3. Run time is faster as well, especially so for programs like ripgrep that use SIMD.
4. Single static binary with no dependencies. Didn't need a VM or toolchain to be installed on the user's computer.
Having a great CLI library like clap.rs brought it all together.
If you think this is simply a cycle and Zig will replace Rust, I'm slightly skeptical. Rust had an easier time competing with the status quo because of the 4 advantages it had.
Zig however, will have to compete with Rust. Sure, you can start ziggrep, but it'll be about equal in all these 4 factors. So why would anyone adopt something that has fewer features than ripgrep and about the same performance, memory consumption and ease of use? Just hype? Some people will, but not enough to get the critical mass ripgrep has.
That's why I'm bullish about Rust - the performance of existing codebases means that in many cases, it's hard to migrate away from it, or replace Rust programs with reimplementations. You'd have to be getting something really unique that Rust doesn't offer. You said Roc, and Roc is actually a great example of benefiting from something unique. Roc plans to reuse the Zig compiler's library that emits LLVM bitcode. There's no Rust equivalent.
But I'd argue that that's pretty niche. How many other examples are there of Zig libraries that have no Rust equivalent? Something that would make Zig the no-brainer choice over Rust, even if you had to reimplement in Zig.
Again, I'm sure people will try to rewrite things in Zig. But I'll confidently assert -> the most popular toolchain for Python in 5 years will be Rust based, not Zig or any other language. $10 on that.