His source of information about goths is a shopping site.[1]
From the guidelines:
> Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.
> Those are attractive people with heavily vetted idiosyncrasies. Every eccentric fashion choice has been run through a think tank of NYU undergrads that would blow your hair back
> But their actual deal is cookie-cutter counterculture, like it came out of a street punk paint-by-numbers kit
More than a shallow criticism, the fact that the article links to it at all puts the whole thing in question.