> > >
> > > That is great, but that does not give you memory safety and everyone
> > > would still need to learn C++.
> >
> > The point is that C++ is a superset of C, and we would use a subset of C++
> > that is more "C+"-style. That is, most changes would occur in header files,
> > especially early on. Since the kernel uses a lot of inlines and macros,
> > the improvements would still affect most of the existing kernel code,
> > something you simply can't do with Rust.
I have yet to see a compelling argument for allowing a completely new language with a completely different compiler and toolchain into the kernel while continuing to bar C++ entirely, when even just a restricted subset could bring safety- and maintainability-enhancing features today, such as RAII, smart pointers, overloadable functions, namespaces, and templates, and do so using the existing GCC toolchain, which supports even recent vintages of C++ (e.g., C++20) on Linux's targeted platforms.
Greg's response:
> But for new code / drivers, writing them in rust where these types of bugs just can't happen (or happen much much less) is a win for all of us, why wouldn't we do this? C++ isn't going to give us any of that any decade soon, and the C++ language committee issues seem to be pointing out that everyone better be abandoning that language as soon as possible if they wish to have any codebase that can be maintained for any length of time.
side-steps this. Even if Rust is "better," it's much easier to address at least some of C's shortcomings with C++, and it can be done without significantly rewriting existing code, sacrificing platform support, or the incorporation of a new toolchain.
For example, as pointed out (and as Greg ignored), the kernel is replete with macros--a poor substitute for genuine generic programming that offers no type safety and the ever-present possibility for unintended side effects due to repeated evaluation of the arguments, e.g.:
#define MAX(x, y) (((x) > (y)) ? (x) : (y))
One need only be bitten by this kind of bug once to have it color your perception of C, permanently.