Some information about the education system which produces these results: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_in_Singapore
Some information about the education system which produces these results: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_in_Singapore
Looking specifically at PISA, it's not usually administered at the state level in the US, but when it has, individual states have outperformed national scores, as one should expect.
For example, Massachusetts has scored similarly to Singapore in Reading and Science (zero or small statistical difference between) and not far in Math.[1] It would be a reasonable hypothesis that a PISA score for the Greater Boston schools (pop. 5M) would even further outperform the U.S.
Sweeping country comparisons tend to amplify noise rather than reveal a clear signal, and are often about regression to the mean as much as anything else. It's not impossible to make sound inferences, but it's difficult to avoid motivated reasoning.
In general, I’d caution that presumptuous ideas like “best Americans will always be best” create cultural rot, and then something like DeepSeek happens. The cultural rot deepens when the elites run around trying to save face instead of admitting an opponent’s ingenuity, and aiming to do better. But I am not sure if that’s what you’re trying to imply (that best American students will out compete best students from other countries) but that’s the sense I got from your comment. America is resting on a lot of built-up wealth and power, so even objectively mediocre elites do well here.
I think everyone already knows this, but success in American society is predicated on intergenerational wealth and/or charisma, which is how people like George W. Bush or Trump become presidents despite being academically mediocre. People who make promises of meritocracy would never appoint some natural genius person-of-color as Barron Trump’s boss, for example. How likely do you think that is?
P.S. “person of color” isn’t a category that exists.