Hacker News Reader

> If the entire value of a product can be taken.

But this is not really possible . People switch to identical products made by more ethical or value aligned distributors all the time.

Switching out music streaming services based on artist payouts, or banks based on their climate commitments, buying a game after pirating it to support development. I’m sure someone can think of even better examples.

View on HN

I'd argue it is possible. If a person pirates an album of an artist, that person now owns the album as if they would have paid money for it (from back in the itunes times). Same for an ebook, a game, a movie, ...

You are describing mostly services, where the intellectual property of the product is of no interest to the buyer (e.g. the average Spotify user has no desire to access their codebase or recommendation engine).

Buying a game after pirating has no impact on the product you have today, you already own the intellectual property as is.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com