I'm convinced the absence of evidence is, itself, valuable evidence. The (apparent) single origin of Earth life is a remarkable statistical observation hiding in plain sight.
I'm convinced the absence of evidence is, itself, valuable evidence. The (apparent) single origin of Earth life is a remarkable statistical observation hiding in plain sight.
The limits are not just our technology levels. Many of the signs you want to life for of life are things that we know by laws of physics could not possibly reach us no matter how good the detection equipment is.
That is why SETI looks for radio waves - they are one of the few signals we can detect that could signal life. However we would never detect earth technology levels of just 120 years ago (there is some debate about what we could first detect). There are not many stars within 100 lightyears of earth, so the vast majority of our galaxy (must less the universe) still has no idea we are here. Even radio signals degrade with distance, so there is a limit to how far we can detect them or they can detect us.
In short, while there is absence of evidence, there is reason believe that we don't have enough evidence to declare anything. If we find life that will be conclusive, but the we don't before our sun dies there still won't be enough evidence to state there is none.
Glad you expressed uncertainity. Indeed We can see some exoplanets directly. I also only learned this very recently.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_directly_imaged_exopla...
That isn't how science works. We have an astounding lack of evidence that there is a Flying Spaghetti Monster roaming around the deepest reaches of space, it doesn't indicate anything but the fact that there's a lack of evidence that there is a Flying Spaghetti Monster roaming around the deepest reaches of space. It may not indicate with absolute certainty whether there is or isn't one, but you cannot say its existence is more likely based on lack of evidence for it - that is superstition.
Of course not. What other evidence of absence do you expect to uncover, other than a lack of evidence for existence? Do you expect to go out into space and have some sort of space god hand you a genuine, bona-fide certificate of nonexistence of something?
It is important not to overestimate the strength of the absence of evidence, but setting the strength to zero is just as wrong.
If we look in many places where we expect to find life, because we have a theory that life is easy and essentially appears the cosmological instant it is possible, and we have a theory that the conditions for life are easy and abundant, yet we look out into the universe and see no evidence of this, yes, we are completely justified in adjusting our understanding of the probabilities involved. The more of the universe we see, and the more it lacks various sorts of life (all the way from the simplest, sparsest bacteria-type life up to galaxy-spanning intelligences, each to their own degree) the more we are justified in coming to conclusions about their probabilities.
Another thing people have problems with in this debate is understanding the difference between justified beliefs and true beliefs. If we hypothetically examined all but one-trillionth of the observable universe and found it bereft of any other life, we would be justified in the conclusion that the most likely scenario is that there isn't any. We could end up being wrong if that remaining one-trillionth just so happened to contain other life, but we would still be justified, having collected extensive "absence of evidence". We can not claim that we have seen enough of the universe to know that it is true that there is no other life, and we have not seen enough of it to be justified in claiming there is no bacterial life, but I do feel at this point we are pretty justified in claiming that at least this galaxy and the nearest ones do not have any galaxy-spanning, multi-million-year civilizations in them, for instance. Maybe they're there and they just don't do anything visible, but that's a pretty precise claim.
Scanned how? What's the operational definition of "life" in that hypothetical scenario? Maybe there's life, but you're looking where isn't, or you're missing something you don't classify as "living". Maybe the universal definition of life is vastly broader than we think.
But for now our definitions of life are good enough.
So if I claim that there is a Flying Spaghetti Monster roaming around our solar system, and it is 1000x larger than our sun, emitting a divine brightness so intense that it would burn the eyes of all who gaze upon it, you're 100% justified to say "no there isn't. We would have seen it."
"Aha!" I say, "but absence of evidence is not evidence of absence! Therefore you can't say anything at all about whether there's a supermassive superluminal Giant Spaghetti Monster!". That is absolute nonsense.
> you cannot say its existence is more likely based on lack of evidence for it
If its existence would imply evidence, then you absolutely can judge its likelihood based on whether that evidence exists or not. And you can also judge its likelihood based on a reasonable extrapolation from prior knowledge, by the way. Yes, it is more likely that there is a 10 kg rock orbiting Neptune than a 10^20 kg Spaghetti Monster, even though we have not directly observed either one. We understand the mechanisms by which a small rock comes to orbit a planet. We see that kind of thing all the time. It may be difficult to formalize some of these priors, but that's a failure of our formalisms, not a mandate that we must not use that knowledge when doing science.
Note that the comment you are replying to said nor implied anything of the sort.
That's literally the exact claim being made:
> We have an astounding lack of evidence that there is a Flying Spaghetti Monster roaming around the deepest reaches of space, it doesn't indicate anything but the fact that there's a lack of evidence
A lack of evidence indicates nothing but a lack of evidence. No! That's not true! It's a widely held misconception and it's worth debunking.
> That isn't how science works.
"Science" is a lot of human activities mushed together and there's not "one true way" that it works, except that it is universally done by humans (so far), with all the good and bad that come with that.
> We have an astounding lack of evidence that there is a Flying Spaghetti Monster roaming around the deepest reaches of space
True.
> it doesn't indicate anything but the fact that there's a lack of evidence that there is a Flying Spaghetti Monster roaming around the deepest reaches of space
False.
> It may not indicate with absolute certainty whether there is or isn't one
Nobody has ever cared about "absolute certainty" and science never seriously claims this.
> you cannot say its existence is more likely based on lack of evidence for it
Yes you can! (I charitably assume you meant less likely here, otherwise the entire comment makes no sense, is arguing against a trivial falsehood nobody has ever claimed (certainly not OP), and you had no reason to post it)
> that is superstition
No, it's Bayesian logic; it's the only way humans have ever acquired knowledge.
There, I covered your entire post.
Do you think we investigated closer to 98% or to 2% for possible evidence?