This is unnecessary nitpicking. You can easily derive a logical contradiction of your choice by assuming that a system that can be formally modeled can prove something that cannot be proven within a formal system. If a specific theorem doesn't prove that, a simple corollary will.
If you want to escape the limits of computability, you have to assume that the physical Church–Turing thesis is false. That the reality allows mechanisms that cannot be modeled formally or simulated on any currently plausible computer.