If you have to invest a significant amount of capital to own housing and it isn't a good investment then people won't want to do it. But there are reasons we want to encourage home ownership, so if it actually wasn't a good investment then that would be bad. People would stop doing it. So it's important that the claim actually is incorrect; it can still be a good investment even if the value never goes up, because it avoids you needing to pay rent. If keeping the values flat would result in lower home ownership then doing that might actually be a problem, but it isn't.
The real problem -- the thing people actually care about -- isn't that the value has to go up. It's that they don't want the value to go down. If they paid $500,000 for something which is only worth $100,000 they're going to be pissed. But that's also what needs to happen, hence the impasse.