I think FiveThirtyEight's method is overrated but they basically put the last three elections as 50/50. Given how close the three of them were that seems fair enough.
You may be thinking of Nate Silver's Silver Bulletin [1]. He took the original 538 model with him when he left. The model 538 runs now is something they made up afterwards.
Of course, this isn't a linear game where scores are alternating, so my line of thought isn't completely fair.