In OpenGL all the fun stuff (e.g. the stuff that's in DX9+) is in vendor specific extensions.
A bit like vendor prefixes in CSS, except they can actually be implemented differently, have different names, etc. It's BAD news, and the main reason why 99% of AAA games use DirectX on Windows.
There are few things one might miss in core OpenGL 4.2. If anything any features exposed in extensions building on OGL 4.2 are so new or experimental that D3D doesn't have them at all.
You'll get hundreds of bug reports about game crashing on start.
Testing on old hardware (for <50 000 triangle games it's Intel GMA and Geforce 4 MX and some old Radeon) is a good way to be sure it works on most of computers. Of course game needs to support those old cards only on lowest quality settings.
If the user's GPU doesn't support D3D 11, you have to supply a fallback.
To understand a somewhat more casual audience, it's interesting to contrast the users of Unity: http://unity3d.com/webplayer/hwstats/pages/web-2012Q1-gfxcar...
But you have to be careful: my amateur OpenGL 3d game had problems running on half of computers, especially laptops. It's because various cards support different opengl extensions. You can't use non-power-of-two textures, can't use textures bigger than 512x512 (or other number), can't generate mipmaps automatically, can't have too big display lists.
I thought about optional DirectX renderer when running on Windows, because I've heard it's more standarized.
OpenGL is an awesome platform for those who want system portability IE minecraft, or any other indie developer who wants maximum exposure.
The question development shops would be asking themselves is: will the additional revenues provided by Linux / Mac ports of these games be enough to offset the cost of retraining their people (or hiring new people) who are prepared to do serious OpenGL development?
Moreover, many game companies are using licensed game engines. These engines may not now (or ever) support OpenGL, so the game developers themselves may not have the option to change--even if they did want to.