Hacker News Reader

Comment by kergonath | Hacker News Reader

> Let's make our market as large and attractive as possible!

That would be the rational and sensible solution. This may be why it’s unlikely to happen. I would be happy to be wrong.

View on HN

If only it was so simple, there are of course many conflicting interests in Europe, with certain countries who are more export oriented for instance benefiting from a weak Euro and others from a stronger Euro etc.

But the EU is a single market.

A single one on paper but a heavily divided one in practice where every country wants to be king or at least backstab everyone else to get what it wants.

I sometimes wish we could abolish our nations and replace the current treaties with a voluntary merge of all participating countries, making everyone simply citizens, throwing out all national law books and replacing it with a single Continental one.

Won't happen without a war - so hopefully not within my lifetime, but playing make believe is fun sometimes.

How would a war in Europe unite people under one leadership? See the regions that have been ceded and annexed post WW1 and post WW2, they still have beef with the new host countries bickering about regional autonomy. You can conquer land, but conquering people is a lot more difficult.

The trend is the exact opposite way, a federation of smaller and smaller devolved regions.

Well I never argued for or against a single market, the commentator said it was rational and sensible. That's a way too simple clarification, there are many conflicting interests in the EU for it just to be sensible.

There are. But the good thing is that all these countries get to sit around a table and talk, when there are such disagreements. And things get (mostly) sorted out in a civilised way.

Not sure if you are been to the EU. There is not table where they talk, they just compromis and ignore along the way and then the commission decides everything behind closed doors, which might be your table

A compromise implies a form of discussion. This post is internally inconsistent.

Labour party manifesto explained in this fresh (5 days old), official document.

It also includes context about ongoing emergency EU security meetings and the Trump administration.

No single market, no freedom of movement, unfortunately.

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-...

You should look to Norway https://www.norway.no/en/missions/eu/areas-of-cooperation/th...

EFTA membership is a non-starter. It's not good for the UK, and it's not good for the other EFTA members. Also, EFTA is part of the Schengen area. But not the customs union.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com