I recall growing up in a time when it seemed that pretty much anyone in the middle class could become a landlord as a venue of investment, and many would. But nowadays, at least where I live, it seems that very few people choose that, and the ones who do make it almost a second job, with multiple places they rent out. And at the same time, it seems that more and more properties are owned by firms.
TFA briefly mentions regulatory barriers to becoming a landlord; I wonder if that could be a significant part of the issue.
Market-rate rentals should be the exception, not the norm. Some of them are necessary to house people who have recently moved in the area, especially if they don't expect to stay in the long term. But because market-rate rental units largely displace owner-occupied units, having too many of them is bad for the society.
If the market is working properly then additional units will be built until the price begins to drop. If there are buyers at a viable price then you should expect there to be sellers.
What you are describing is a lack of liquidity. That shouldn't happen in the typical case unless there is bad policy.
Meanwhile, as we wait for the elusive capitalist utopia, there are real-world issues that should be solved. The solutions will likely involve policy changes. Which will likely have both positive and negative outcomes. And the negative outcomes will probably require further policy changes in the future.
We're in agreement. My point was that the issue is due to policy. Landlords aren't the problem. Getting rid of landlords would at best be a tiny bandaid and you'd have to change policy to do it so you might as well just address the root cause.
Personally I’d prefer the state to own more properties.
People tend to imagine a counterfactual where the state is idealized instead of looking at the state they have.
Unless you want "buy" (as opposed to "rent") to be the only option for housing, you need landlords. If there's going to be landlords, you want more of them, because more supply translates to lower prices for consumers. Nobody complains about there being too many farmers, for instance.
I'm ten years older than he was and I still can't afford a house.
Can it be that the issue you're describing explains what's happening in every single state? Has development stalled all across the USA (and abroad) simply due to regulation?
I mean this is pretty trivially true, excepting some markets like Japan. 100-200 thousand dollars of wood and drywall and concrete sells for 0.5 to 2 million in much of the country. People (builders) haven't started hating money, they just aren't allowed to build.
Heck if it were legal I'd personally find some investors, buy up a few 1 million dollar sfh's and replace them with 8 500k condos each.
1. There was a lot of money circulating during the COVID pandemic as a result of very low interest rates and other practices intended to stimulate the economy. More money chasing a limited supply of assets means that those assets cost more.
2. WFH during COVID made many areas of the country more desirable since those with remote jobs were not limited to the locations of their employers. I’ve seen exurban areas in California face skyrocketing home prices in 2020-2021 due to WFH demand; Los Baños is a prime example.
3. There may have been increased demand in second- and third-tier cities from those who have been priced out of first- and second-tier cities. For example, Sacramento (my hometown) always gets a large number of former Bay Area residents whenever housing prices in the latter place spike.