Then OS X is not supposed to overwrite your file without your consent, but it does in this case.
Then OS X is not supposed to overwrite your file without your consent, but it does in this case.
Before displaying the Save As dialog for naming your new file a write to the original takes place. They probably just do a copy and rename file operation afterwards.
Interesting fact: if you abort the Save As dialog and try to close the original they ask you to "Revert Changes".
The old model was revert-by-default. You had to manually save your changes.
The new model is save-by-default. You have to manually revert your changes.
In the "File" -> "Revert To..." menu you have multiple options, such as revert to last saved document and revert to last opened document. These persist even after restarting the application.
I think the new model is far better design.