Carriers blame the iPhone for data caps and increased upgrade fees
bgr.com
bgr.com
It would seem pretty simple then - stop carrying and supporting the iPhone, and they would have higher profit margins. This is basic math. If they want higher profit margins, drop iPhone.
Wait... what? They want higher profit margins and higher revenues? Perhaps those days are slipping away, and they may have to deal with higher revenues and 'only' 20% profit margins.
Uh oh - what if that happens? We'll stop seeing all the innovations from carriers we've seen over the past 20 years like...
Oh yeah, we haven't really seen any. SMS spam? That's been the only change in my wireless life I can directly attribute to wireless carriers, other than wireless service itself. Is there anything else I'm missing?
I don't want to be in the position of defending the cellphone networks too much, but things like 3G and LTE upgrades to cell towers aren't easy or free. Neither were the 4G auctions.
Your analogy could just as well be used like: the first food preparation was mixing together ingredients, sometimes with heat. Modern cooking is mixing together ingredients, sometimes with heat.
I don't particularly love my carrier, but I have a choice of several and they bring me mostly-available mostly-quite-high-speed service for a small fraction of my paycheck. It would've blown me away 20 years ago to have such service on a wired connection.
Lower latency, cheaper, wider range, higher volume, diffserved, sorted, tabulated, billed, whatever, sure: if you define implementation improvements as "innovations" then the carriers are innovating. But the thing the customer consumes is the same as the first day they lit up the first network: timely data to a computationally-capable handset.
The telco's have had a monopoly position for too long. The consumer does not care if his call is routed over the internet, skype, broadband or 3g, he just wants his connection, and wants it cheap.
Data limits and increased prices are not the way to solve this, evolving the infrastructure is.
And don't tell me they need to make huge investments. They've got a vastly automated infrastructure and millions of customers that they're leeching off monthly.
Firstly , I'd be amazed if the TOS for my from most domestic ISPs actually allow you to "resell" your connection in such a way.
Secondly what happens if somebody uses your connection for nefarious deeds, how can you prove it wasn't you?
If you're in a densely populated area, someone could spend the time to break your encryption from their own home. But if they're doing that, they're going to be doing worse once you let them in. Open wifi will only compound your issues. If you're not within range of your neighbors, you'll probably notice someone sitting outside for long enough (weeks/months/years) to break your encryption. Long enough to call the police.
Basically, if you're worried about a possible legal case involving the use of your network and your defense strategy is to open your network, you might be in much more immediate trouble by allowing people in. You'd still be on the hook for the activities on your network, but now your bank account has been drained by the guys who did nothing more than drive by your house with a laptop so now you don't have the money for a legal defense.
It's certainly enough of a gray area that I wouldn't want to get involved.