Says someone who has never experienced a data loss bug.
I'm not at all saying that soft deletion shouldn't exist. I'm arguing that hard deletion should be the default, and then soft deletion practices should have some justification.
Instead the industry chose to just soft delete everywhere, which is good for the industry, and bad for users.
It should just be followed up by hard delete several days or weeks later. The general policy should never be to hold things indefinitely.
As a practical example I have soft deletion for more or less everything on my desktop. There are periodic filesystem level snapshots and those stick around until I manually GC them. It has saved me more than once.