> Which one would you pick?
Well I'd remove the stupid fucking fake scroll bar from http://www.wikipediaredefined.com for starters. It's horribly unusable on Safari.
- my trackpoint isn't precise enough to move the slider at a reasonable speed;
- there's no click-to-scroll-up/-down buttons, common to pretty much all native scrollbars;
- the up/down arrow keys don't work on that page, either;
- oh, and it's ugly, as well as breaking the user's interface expectations.
I am using latest firefox on latest fedora and I don't see any problems. No fake scrollbars either.
Maybe it has been fixed ?
There was originally some "arty" looking scroll bar that looked like it was hand-rolled out of images and javascript, and completely failed to have any of the many subtle features that native scrollbars have gained over the years.