I would immediately surrender such information either way, in the interests of the community - say for a missing child?
These capabilities should have well defined intent/objectives and transparent controls to protect the privacy of individuals to which are out scope.
With all the above said; it’s been proven time and time again that even with clear intent - the purpose of these systems mutates (ie between governments). Said governments then wonder why public trust is lacking?
(Example; see Australian Government customer ISP DNS requirements)