The reason it feels silly to not use an Apple ID is because Apple will create un-dismissable nag indicators in Settings and elsewhere begging you to log in for iCloud functionality.
I’ve never tried it so I’ll take your word for it. To me the reason it feels silly is because iCloud functionality is really good.
To me the reason it feels silly is because iCloud is a paid subscription service and I am constantly advertised it even when using something like Syncthing or Nextcloud to provide equivalent support.