I also don't understand why the MAS is a dud and this would be any better. Steam's standards and review process are way more strict and cryptic than Apple's. Plenty of indie devs have felt the sting of Steam rejection. I have little doubt they will also require sandboxing.
Is it just the cross platform aspect? Everything else about it seems to be the same or worse. Not to mention Steam's integration with its host OS is just awful. It's like a completely segmented world rarely following any UI guidelines or making any attempt to fit in.
If you're a developer and you make an app that doesn't violate the rules of the store, you should be able to submit it. That's how the App Store works.
Having to rally community support with no promise of what the threshold for acceptance is is crazy. Doesn't seem more transparent or less cryptic to me at all.
Note that I said "will" not "does".
>If you're a developer and you make an app that doesn't violate the rules of the store, you should be able to submit it.
You can. That's just no guarantee you'll get in.
>Having to rally community support with no promise of what the threshold for acceptance is is crazy.
Allowing every random to put their garbage up on a trusted store with no vetting is crazier. There's a reason the Google Market is a bit like the wild west. Malware and adware and garbage, oh my!