Literally any introductory Econ book would explain why this is nonsense. It’s depressing that this mindset is resonating with so many people who think it’s better to put massive taxes on basic necessities (tariffs are taxes) and destroy the economy.
It doesn’t make sense for the US to allow other exporters in other countries free access to US consumers, while other countries charge US exporters for the same privilege.
I think you misunderstood the message you’re trying to stand behind: when they talk about reciprocity they mean trade deficits (as if that made sense), not import tariffs. The majority of the world had very low import taxes on US products before this happened, and now they are only going up.
And the understanding of the problem exhibited being so infantile it can't even conceive of circular trade does not give one confidence that there's any sort of great game theory happening.