1. productivity and quality is hard to measure
2. the codebase they are ruining is the same one I am working on.
We're supposed to have a process for dealing with this already, because developers can ruin a codebase without ai.
"more code faster" is not a good thing, it has never been a good thing
I'm not worried about pro AI workers ruining their codebases at their jobs
I'm worried about pro AI coworkers ruining my job by shitting up the codebases I have to work in
Pump the brakes there
You may have bought into some PMs idea of what we do, but I'm not buying it
As professional, employed software developers, the entire point of what we do is to provide value to our employers.
That isn't always by delivering features to users, it's certainly not always by delivering features faster
Why the hand-wringing? Well, for one thing, as a developer I still have to work on that code, fix the bugs in it, maintain it etc. You could say that this is a positive since AI slop would provide for endless job security for people who know how to clean up after it - and it's true, it does, but it's a very tedious and boring job.
But I'm not just a developer, either - I'm also a user, and thinking about how low the average software quality already is today, the prospect of it getting even worse across the board is very unpleasant.
And as for things taking care of themselves, I don't think they will. So long as companies can still ship something, it's "good enough", and cost-cutting will justify everything else. That's just how our economy works these days.
If a company fails to compete in the market and dies, there is no "autopsy" that goes in and realizes that it failed because of a chain-reaction of factors stemming from bad AI-slop code. And execs are so far removed from the code level, they don't know either, and their next company will do the same thing.
What you're likely to end up with is project managers and developers who do know the AI code sucks, and they'll be heeded by execs just as much they are now, which is to say not at all.
And when the bad AI-code-using devs apply to the next business whose execs are pro-AI because they're clueless, guess who they'll hire?