A human society may develop their own math in a base 13 system, or an entirely different way of representing the same concepts. When they can't solve our base 10 math problems in a way that matches how we expect does that mean they are parrots?
Part of the problem here is that we still have yet to land on a clear, standard definition of intelligence that most people agree with. We could look to IQ, and all of its problems, but then we should be giving LLMs an IQ test to answer rather than a math test.